MOLECULAR DYNAMICS INVESTIGATION FOR THE IMPACT OF METAKAOLIN ON MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF THE ORDINARY PORTLAND CEMENTHTML Full Text
MOLECULAR DYNAMICS INVESTIGATION FOR THE IMPACT OF METAKAOLIN ON MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF THE ORDINARY PORTLAND CEMENT
R. K. Hussein * 1, A. T. Hassan 2 and A. Alkaoud 1
Department of Physics, College of Science 1, Imam Mohammad Ibn Saud Islamic University (IMSIU), Riyadh 11623, KSA.
Department of Basic Science October High institute of Engineering & Technology-OHI 2, 2nd Neighbourhood, 3rd District, 6th of October Giza, Egypt.
ABSTRACT: The incorporation of Ordinary Portland cement with additional cementing materials is one of the most efficient methods to improve its microscopic properties. The aim of this work is to investigate the effect of metakaolin on Portland cement performance by using theoretical methods. 14 Å tobermorite was used as an alternative familiar molecular structure in representing Ordinary Portland cement. A constituting theoretical model has been constructed to describe the structure of Portland cement mixed with different ratios of metakaolin. This model was subjected to molecular dynamics simulations, and force field methodologies were employed to investigate the mechanical properties behavior. The results revealed an effective influence of metakaolin on the mechanical stiffness properties of Portland cement. The values of mechanical stiffness parameters (Bulk, Shear, and Young’s Modulus) were increased by increasing the metakaolin concentration.
Ordinary Portland cement, Metakaolin, Molecular dynamics, Force fields, Mechanical properties
INTRODUCTION: Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) is one of the most common types of different cement materials and is considered a dominant material in construction industries. At high temperature, quartz, clay, limestone, shale, and iron oxides are all reacting together and then synthesis at high temperature, which is known as clinkering followed by cooling to produce OPC 1. The hydration in Portland cement chemistry is described as a series of chemical reactions. The mixing of cement powder with water generates a sequence of physical changes and thermodynamical processes 2.
Calcium silicate hydrates (C-S-H) are a principal product of cement hydration and participate as the main building blocks of concrete. C-S-H is an amorphous compound that has a different arrangement of CaO, SiO2, and H2O phases with different calcium/silicon ratios. The complicated nonstoichiometric structure of C-S-H left many problems to study 3. Incorporation of cement clinkers with other chemical additives has been regarded as a powerful method to enhance per-formance, get more economic benefits as well as protecting the environment.
Recently, many cementations materials have been used as substitutions portions in cement-based materials 4. Polyolefin fibers and silica fume in mixes with cement-based composites demonstrated an extra positive effect on the properties of paste cement 5. Micro-fillers named brick and glass powders achieved excellent values of flexural and compressive strength of concrete 6.
Sergey et al., described the mechanism of Al incorporation into calcium-silicate hydrate (C-S-H) for the development of novel cementitious materials with a lower CO2 7. The replacement of natural course of concrete with magnetite aggregates was evaluated by Afsaneh Valizadeh to obtain heavyweight concrete 8.
Metakaolin (MK) is classified as the most supplementary cementitious material (SCMs) without a detrimental impact on the environment. MK is an amorphous primary product of kaolinite, which exhibits strong pozzolanic properties. Production of MK by thermal treatment (calcination) of kaolin within 450 to 850 °C temperature ranges 9. There is a great interest in MK as one of the highly reactive chemical admixtures used to improve the intrinsic characterizations of concrete. Shrinkage and creep of concrete mixtures were reduced by partial replacement of MK at different concentrations up to 15% 10. The impact of MK incorporated in concrete mixtures leads to high strength concrete 11.
The reduction of CO2 emissions from Portland cement industries is the primary target for MK in addition 12. High reactivity MK led to lower porosity, denser microstructure, and best chemical corrosion resistance for concrete 13. The influence of the MK addition on Portland cement was mostly provided by experimental studies, and there is a significant lack of theoretical investigations in this framework.
Theoretical techniques have shown remarkable outcomes in the field of material science investigations, and they were extensively used for cement clinker studies. Molecular dynamics are the most dominant simulation method in cement studies 14, 15. In Molecular dynamics, the motion of molecule and atoms could be simulated at predefined parameter conditions, such as volume, pressure, temperature, and external forces. This is done by solving Newton’s equations of motion numerically for a set of atoms specified in an initial configuration 16. The Force field is the potential interatomic principle used to express the interaction between dissimilar particles in molecular dynamics. Many force fields have been formulated to figure parameters for all types of atoms in the specified system. For example, CFF, CVFF, AMBER, CHARMM, GROMOS, ReaxFF, and so many other types of known force field 17.
The main objective under the present work is to use molecular dynamics simulation to model the impact of MK at different concentrations on the mechanical properties of OPC.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Structural Building: C-S-H is a very complex composition containing many phases intermixed with each other, which makes it extremely difficult from a research point of view. Many efforts were made to find a structure or composition analogue to C-S-H. 14 Å tobermorite has a significant key function in interpreting the true structure of C - S - H. There are a series of experimental and theoretical evidence confirmed that the structure of C-S-H could be described as a 14 Å tobermorite 18-20. Therefore, this study is based on using 14 Å tobermorite as a similar structure to the C-S-H phase. Fig. 1 shows the crystal structure of 14 Å tobermorite. It is monoclinic unit cell (B11b space group) with lattice parameters a= 6.735 Å, b=7.425 Å, c=27.987Å, α=β=90°, γ=123.25°. This con-figuration was described by Elena Bonaccorsi and Stefano Merlino in the refinement of the crystal structure of 14 Å tobermorite 21. As mentioned above, MK is produced from kaolin by calcination at a temperature between 450 to 850 °C.
FIG. 1: UNIT CELL OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE
The structure of MK is mainly composed of silica (SiO2, 44.4-73%) and Aluminum oxide (Al2O3, 14.5–47.43%) 22. Mac Kenzie proposed a structural model in trying to depicture the MK by nuclear magnetic resonance and computer simulation studies. The lattice unit assumed in this model is shown in Fig. 2, in which the existence of residual OH groups (11–12%) incorporated in the Al-O layers was adopted 23. Xiao Yao et al. succeeded in revealing the geopolymerization process of MK activated by alkali and alkali silicate solutions by using MK lattice supposed by MacKenzie 24. Also, Olesia Mikhailova and Pavel Rovnaník used the same model to study the MK-based geopolymer, including different polymer admixtures 25.
FIG. 2: METAKAOLINITE LATTICE UNIT PROPOSED BY MACKENZIE
4×4×4 supercell building structure of 14 Å tobermorite is shown in Fig. 3 (left). The number of Ca atoms in the supercell is the same number as Si atoms which achieve calcium/silicon ratio of 1.00. Based on previous studies, MK acts as a micro-filter occupies the gap spaces between cement particles to increase the density of the solid skeleton of the binder phase 26, 27.
FIG. 3: - 4×4×4 SUPERCELL OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE (LEFT). CONFIGURATIONS OF MK INCORPORATION IN THE SUPERCELL (RIGHT)
On this basis, MK incorporation in 14 Å tober-morite will be satisfied by inserting the MK lattice unit Fig. 4 into the interstitial space of the super-cell. The unit of MK constitutes 2 % wt of 14 Å tobermorite supercell. Therefore, one MK unit embedded in 14 Å tobermorite interlayer spaces denoting 2% MK incorporation, two units of MK representing 4% and so on. Fig. 3 (right) shows the different configuration of 14 Å tobermorite super cells and their corresponding MK percentage.
FIG. 4: LATTICE UNIT OF METAKAOLINITE
Computational Details: The molecular dynamics calculations were done by using Atomistix Tool Kit (Atomic-Scale Modeling for Semiconductor and Materials) 28. The interaction of atoms was described by employing Reax FF classical force field potential 29. The canonical ensemble NVT was used at finite temperature to find the global minimum with 5000 steps and time step set to 1fs. The mechanism to search the global minimum is known as annealing in which the temperature increases periodically from room temperature to target temperature, followed by decreasing the temperature once again to the initial temperature. Nose Hoover algorithm were considered to control the temperature. Finally, the deformed con-figuration became in thermodynamic equilibrium and ready for analyzing to determine elastic constants. The corresponding elastic moduli are obtained from the second derivative of the optimized structures. The bulk (K) and shear (G) were determined from the Voigt-Reuss-Hill (VRH) approximation 30. The Young’s modulus (E) and Poisson’s ratio (ν) are determined through the following relations:
E = 9G / (3 + G / K) ………… (1)
V = (3 - 2G / K) / (6 + 2G / K)……………(2)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: The calculated mechanical stiffness properties, K: bulk modulus; G: shear modulus; ν: Poisson’s ratio and E: elastic modulus; of the proposed 14Å tobermoritesupercell are recorded in Table 1.
TABLE 1: MECHANICAL STIFFNESS PROPERTIES OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE SUPERCELLS
|K (GPa)||G (GPa)||E (GPa)||ν|
In the recent work of Jae Eun Oh et al., the bulk modulus of 14 Å tobermorite was determined experimentally by using high-pressure synchrotron X-ray diffraction 31, 32. In this work, the value of bulk modulus was 47 GPa with only 7.61 GPa greater than our investigated value. As for theoretical investigations, force field atomistic methods have been applied by H. Manzano et al. to evaluate the elastic properties of the most important phases present in cement pastes 33.
Among the results included in this work, the values of B, G, ν and E for 14 Å tobermorite (Ca/Si = 1.00) have yielded 33.7 GPa, 18.5 GPa, 46.92 GPa and 0.27 respectively, which is highly comparable to the findings set out here. The study presented by Ratan Mishra in the survey of force field database for cementitious materials (B= 44GPa, G=22 GPa, E=56.57 GPa and ν = 0.29) are very similar to the estimations in the current study 34. Also, the results obtained are considered reliable and very close to that reported by Shahsavari et al., (35.91 GPa, 20.61 GPa, 51.90 GPa, 0.25) with a percentage of difference less than 10% 35. The predicted bulk modulus values for MK -modified 14 Å tobermorite are displayed in Fig. 5. It can be noted that the value of bulk modulus increases along with increasing the MK amount. The increases are in a small rate of 2%, 4% and 6% of MK concentration. The maximum value (B= 69.21 Gpa) was achieved at 10% MK. The variation in shear modulus of 14 Å tobermorite corresponding to the variation content of MK is shown in Fig. 6.
The results indicated that, while the ratio of MK increased from 0 to 10%, the estimated shear modulus values increased from 20.12 to 31.43 Gpa. Fig. 7 illustrates the computed data of Young's modulus. Generally, the addition of MK gradually increases the values of Young's modulus similar to those of bulk and shear modulus, except for Young's modulus attains higher final increment at 10% MK compared to the initial value moduli of 14 Å tobermorite were found to be in a good agreement with both experimental results and previous molecular dynamics calculations.
The Bulk, Shear, and Young’s Modulus of 14 Å tobermorite increase with the increase of MK content from 2 to 10%.
FIG. 5: BULK MODULUS OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE VERSUS MK CONTENT
FIG. 6: SHEAR MODULUS OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE VERSUS MK CONTENT
FIG. 7: YOUNG'S MODULUS OF 14 Å TOBERMORITE VERSUS MK CONTENT
CONCLUSION: In the current study, the Theoretical model was developed for OPC-MK composition, and molecular dynamics calculations were used to demonstrate the impact of MK incorporation in the OPC. The molecular structure of 14 Å tobermorite was used as a representation for complex OPC. The mechanical stiffness properties of 14 Å tobermorite with different ratios of MK were evaluated. The results showed that the estimated elastic moduli of 14 Å tobermorite were found to be in good agreement with both experimental results and previous molecular dynamics calculations. The Bulk, Shear, and Young’s Modulus of 14 Å tobermorite increase with the increase of MK content from 2 to 10%.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST: Nil
- Naqi A and Jeong J: Recent progress in green cements technology utilizing low-carbon emission fuels and raw materials: a review. Sustainabilit 2019; 11: 537-42.
- Dwivedi VN, Shiva SD, Nakshatra BS, Sarita R and Namdev SG: portland cements hydration in the presence of admixtures: black gram pulse and super plasticizer. Materials Research 2008; 11: 427-31.
- Skinner LB, SR Chae, CJ Benmore, HR Wenk and Monteiro PJM: Nanostructure of calcium silicate hydrates in cements. Physical Review Letters 2010; 104: 195502.
- Olutoge A, Habeeb A and Oladipupo S: Investigation of the strength properties of palm kernel shell ash concrete. Engineering Technology & Applied Science Research 2012; 2: 5-11.
- Maruyama I and Igarashi G: Cement Reaction and Resultant Physical Properties of Cement Paste. Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology 2014; 12: 200-13.
- Sičáková A and Špak M: The effect of a high amount of micro-fillers on the long-term properties of concrete. Materials 2019; 12: 3421-28.
- Churakov V and Christophe L: Thermodynamics and molecular mechanism of al incorporation in calcium silicate hydrates. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017; 121: 4412-19.
- Valizadeh A, Farhad A, Zohaib A and Matt R: Development of heavyweight self-compacting concrete and ambient-cured heavyweight geopolymer concrete using magnetite aggregates. Materials 2019; 12: 1035.
- Biljana I, Mitrovic A and Milicic L: Thermal Treatment of Kaolin Clay to Obtain Metakaolin. Hemijska Industrija 2010; 64: 351-56.
- Brooks JJ and Megat Johari MA: Effect of metakaolin on creep and shrinkage of concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites 2001; 23: 495-02.
- Dinakar P, Pradosh KS and Sriram G: Effect of metakaolin content on the properties of high strength concrete. Int J of Concrete Structures and Materials 2013; 7: 215-23.
- Worrell L, Nathan M, Chris H and Leticia O M: C Arbon d ioxide E missions from the g lobal C ement I ndustry. Annual Review of Energy and the Envir 2001; 26: 303-29.
- Wang W, Xinhao L, Liang G and Ping D: Evaluation of properties and microstructure of cement paste blended with Metakaolin Subjected to High Temperatures. Materials 2019; 12: 941.
- Hou D, Zeyu L, Xiangyu L, Hongyan M and Zongjin L: Reactive molecular dynamics and experimental study of graphene-cement composites: structure, dynamics and reinforcement mechanisms. Carbon 2017; 115: 188-08.
- Zehtab B and Tarighat A: Diffusion Study for Chloride Ions and Water Molecules in C-S-H Gel in Nano-Scale Using Molecular Dynamics: Case Study of Tobermorite. Advances in Concrete Construction 2016; 4: 305-17.
- Martyna GJ, Michael LK and Tuckerman M: Nosé-Hoover Chains: The Canonical Ensemble via Continuous Dynamics. The J of Chemical Physics 1992; 97: 2635-43.
- Monticelli L and Peter D: Force Fields for Classical Molecular Dynamicsin. Totowa NJ Humana Press 2013.
- Richardson G: Model Structures for C-(A)-S-H (I)’, Acta Crystallographica Section B Structural Science. Crystal Engineering and Materials 2014; 70: 903-23.
- Houston JR, Robert SM and Susan AC: Transformation of Meta-Stable Calcium Silicate Hydrates to Tobermorite: Reaction Kinetics and Molecular Structure from XRD and NMR Spectroscopy. Geochemical Transact 2009; 10: 1-9.
- Grangeon S, Francis C, Yannick L and Christophe C: X-Ray Diffraction: A Powerful Tool to Probe and Understand the Structure of Nanocrystalline Calcium Silicate Hydrates. Acta Crystallographica Section B Structural Science Crystal Engineering and Materials 2013; 69: 465-73.
- Bonaccorsi E, Stefano M and Anthony RK: The Crystal Structure of Tobermorite 14 A (Plombierite), a C-S-H Phase. J of the American Ceramic Soc 2008; 88: 505-12.
- Rakhimova NR and Ravil ZR: Reaction Products, Structure and Properties of Alkali-Activated Metakaolin Cements Incorporated with Supplementary Materials - a Review. Journal of Materials Research and Technology 2019; 8: 1522-31.
- Varga G: The Structure of Kaolinite and Metakaolinite. Epitoanyag - Journal of Silicate Based and Composite Materials 2007; 59: 6-9.
- Yao X, Zuhua Z, Huajun Z and Yue C: Geopolymerization Process of Alkali-Metakaolinite Characterized by Isothermal Calorimetry. Thermoch Acta 2009; 493: 49-54.
- Mikhailova O and Pavel R: Study of Metakaolin-Based Geopolymer with Addition of Polymer Admixtures. International Journal of Chemical and Molecular Engineering 2016; 10: 5-11.
- Chen JJ, Li QH, Ng PL, Li LG and Kwan AKH: Cement Equivalence of Metakaolin for Workability, Cohesiveness, Strength and Sorptivity of Concrete. Materials 2020; 13: 1646-51.
- Chu SH and Kwan AKH: Co-Addition of Metakaolin and Silica Fume in Mortar: Effects and Advantages. Construction and Building Materials 2019; 197: 716-24.
- Smidstrup S, Troels M, Pieter V, Jess W, Julian S and Tue G: Quantum ATK: An Integrated Platform of Electronic and Atomic-Scale Modelling Tools. Journal of Physics Condensed Matter 2020; 32: 015901.
- van D, Adri CT, Siddharth D, Francois L and William A G: ReaxFF: A Reactive Force Field for Hydrocarbons. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2001; 105: 939609.
- Man C S and Mojia H: A Simple Explicit Formula for the Voigt-Reuss-Hill Average of Elastic Polycrystals with Arbitrary Crystal and Texture Symmetries. Journal of Elasticity 2011; 105: 29-48.
- Oh JE, Simon MC, Hans RW and Paulo JM M: Experimental Determination of Bulk Modulus of 14Å Tobermorite Using High Pressure Synchrotron X-Ray Diffraction. Cement and Concrete Rese 2012; 42: 397-403.
- Oh JE, Simon MC and Paulo JMM: Does the Al Substitution in C-S-H (I) Change Its Mechanical Property. Cement and Concrete Research 2011; 41: 102-6.
- Manzano HJS and Ayuela A: Elastic Properties of the Main Species Present in Portland Cement Pastes. Acta Materialia 2009; 57: 1666-74.
- Mishra K, Aslam M, David G, Hegoi M, Tariq J and Rouzbeh S: A Force Field Database for Cementitious Materials Including Validations, Applications and Opportunities. Cement and Concr Res 20017; 102: 68-89.
- Shahsavari R, Markus JB, Roland JMP and Franz JU: First-Principles Study of Elastic Constants and Interlayer Interactions of Complex Hydrated Oxides: Case Study of Tobermorite and Jennite. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 2009; 92: 2323-30.
How to cite this article:
Hussein RK, Hassan AT and Alkaoud A: Molecular dynamics investigation for the impact of metakaolin on mechanical properties of the ordinary portland cement. Int J Pharm Sci & Res 2020; 11(10): 5192-97. doi: 10.13040/IJPSR.0975-8232.11(10).5192-97.
All © 2013 are reserved by the International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research. This Journal licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
R. K. Hussein *, A. T. Hassan and A. Alkaoud
Department of Physics, College of Science, Imam Mohammad Ibn Saud Islamic University (IMSIU), Riyadh, KSA.
24 July 2020
19 August 2020
22 September 2020
01 October 2020